I'm not sure if this is the Samuel Colwell or the John Sutton Home. In the 1850 Census, Samuel Colwell, age 43, is listed as living in this area along with Susan Colwell age 41,William age 19, Samuel Jr. age 17, Eleanor age 15, Susan Jr. age 13, Richard age 11, Wisener age 9, Elizabeth age 7, John age 3, Daniel Dean age 43(mulatto), Timothy Collins age 50(born in Ireland) and Mary Rainor(Raynor) age 28.

Also in the same area is John Sutton, age 32, Eleanor H. age 27, Emma L. age 6, Alonzo C. age 4, Silas age 8 months, Simpronia Gessen age 18 and Jesse Gibson age 14.

Update:

This house was known as the Newberry Homestead prior to belonging to Samuel Colwell or John Sutton. Check out this site for more information about the very interesting history of this house and property.

The Newberry Homestead